Italian regionalist parties and the Constitutional Referendum

Italians vote today in a constitutional referendum which is being ridiculously over-simplified by the British media as the third round of battles between Brexit/Trumpite populism and the ‘Establishment’. It isn’t.

Yes, Italy’s populist (though hardly far-right Ukip-lite) Five Star Movement is calling for a No vote, as is the right-wing autonomist Lega Nord. But then, so is Sinistra Italiana (Italian Left), which combines former Communists, other left-wingers and greens. Meanwhile, one conservative party (the New Centre-Right) is found in the Yes camp, while a second – the Conservatives and Reformists – which explicitly and unaccountably models itself on the British Tories – is in the No camp.

The problem with this referendum is that it can easily be read as a centralising move that neatly fits the anti-democratic project of the neo-liberal elites running Europe (and the UK). Matteo Renzi, the Italian Democratic Party (similar to Labour) Prime Minister is making this an issue of confidence and sees himself as a ‘moderniser’. But this is business-friendly, Blairite ‘modernisation’. It’s no coincidence that the Italian employers’ organisation backs a Yes vote, as does the European Commission, while stock markets are getting jittery about a No vote.

The Italian autonomous regions
The Italian autonomous regions

Fundamentally, the constitutional reform proposes weakening and reducing in size the Italian Senate. It replaces direct elections to the Senate by indirect elections (by Regional Councils). While this still leaves the Italian Senate more democratic than our House of Lords, it also means the Chamber of Deputies becomes the dominant element in the formerly bicameral constitution. At the same time, some argue that ordinary regions in Italy will be rendered powerless, although the five autonomous regions (Val d’Aosta, Trentino, Friulia-Venezia Giulia, Sicily and Sardinia) are left untouched. Meanwhile rural provinces, a level of local government, look likely to be abolished.

The PATT in Trentino calls for a Yes vote
The PATT in Trentino calls for a Yes vote

So where do Italian regionalist parties stand on the referendum? Of the five members of the European Free Alliance (the group that contains the SNP, Plaid and MK), four are calling for a No vote, even those in unaffected regions. In the Val d’Aosta the EFA member and leftist Autonomie-Liberté-Participation-Ecologie supports No, while the centre-right Union Valdôtaine is on the Yes side. This mirrors the position of the dominant catch-all parties in South Tyrol and Trentino, the Südtiroler Volkspartei and the Partito Autonomista Trentino Tirolese, which are both supporting Renzi. But again, the EFA member, the centre-right Süd-Tiroler Freiheit says No. In Venetia, the EFA’s Liga Veneta Repubblica is now part of Noi Veneto Indipendente, which strongly supports No. Finally, the Sardinian Partito Sardo d’Azione calls for a No vote too. (The fifth EFA member – the Slovene Union – I’m not sure about as I can’t read Slovene well enough!)

Noi Veneto Indipendente explains why Venetians should vote No
Noi Veneto Indipendente explains why Venetians should vote No

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.